How do you respond to a referee report?
How do you respond to a referee report?
Just begin with something like this: “Thank you for the opportunity to revise my paper. I have commented below on each of the points raised by the referees.” Please respond to all of the major points made by the referees. Just saying “We have done what the referees asked” is insufficient.
What is a referee reference report?
Referee reports are an assessment method where supervisors or other people with direct personal knowledge of an applicant’s skills, knowledge and/or experience are asked to provide information on their performance against the selection criteria of the advertised vacancy.
How long should a referee report be?
The length of this report should be between 2 or 3 pages of typed text, 12 pt font, and 1.5 line spacing. 2) A letter to the editor with a recommendation on whether the paper should be published. The recommendation should be briefly justified (the length of the letter should be between 10 and 15 lines of typed text).
How do you address a referee comment?
“Thank you” also is an appropriate reply to a referee’s compliment when preparing a response to reviews. Authors should take pains to address all comments made by the AE and referees because referees probably will read the published paper and may use it in their teaching or reference it in their publications.
How do you respond to referee comments for scientific articles?
It will be reasonable to begin the letter with a sentence like” Thank you for giving me a chance of revising my manuscript.” Your responses should be scientific, and systematic. You may get help from other authors or before sending your reply you may ask other authors to read, and review your manuscript.
How do I respond to reviewer comments?
Responding to reviewers’ comments
- Begin by thanking the reviewer for taking the time to assess your manuscript.
- Then, specify that you’ve addressed all the concerns they raised.
- List all the reviewer’s comments and your answer to each one.
- Avoid giving yes or no answers.
How do you write an author response?
General themes for writing the response
- Be polite and appreciative.
- Do not address every concern.
- Address the main concerns first.
- Reference the key concerns in a manner close to how the reviewers phrased them, so they are easy to find.
- Reference your own paper for answers to reviewer concerns.
How do you respond to an article?
Responses include answering the following:
- What do you think about the ideas in the article? Do you agree or disagree?
- How do the ideas in the article relate to your own experiences?
- How do the ideas in the article relate to other things you’ve read?
- What do you notice about the way the article is written?
What are the basic elements of a referee report form?
The Basic Elements of Referee Report Forms. In completing the referee report forms, there are few information that are essential in order to complete the form. Thus, refer below for the general information that are necessary to be provided: The applicant information the full name (last name and the given names) the date of birth.
How do I submit my referee report?
These referee reports may be submitted thru personal delivery, post, and/or email which are provided by the management. The applicants may also include their individual referee report as they submit their application form. It is important that this is sealed in an envelope in order to avoid disclosing any information with regards to this.
What should a referee do when evaluating an applicant?
Referees should be honest when evaluating the applicant, and that they should note in the form if they do not know the applicant well enough. Referees should be able to submit a letter of reference, when necessary. This is in order to support the general statement and results of the referee report forms.
Can a referee be a close friend of the applicant?
The referees should not be a family relative or a close friend of the applicant. The referee report forms should be a frank assessment for performance of an applicant. The referees should be kept reminded of the deadline for the submission of referee report forms.
